📡 Idea Radar 每天 8:00 / 18:00 推送 · 18:00 生成精选
reddit · SideProject · 48 分 ← 返回列表

I built a memory-backed reviewer that tells you what your own company already got wrong

Hi all, I've been building this and would like honest feedback. The problem: every company has already made the decision you're about to make. It's in a Slack thread from 18 months ago, a doc nobody reopens, and a postmortem that says "this has happened before" with nothing behind it. What it does: you describe a decision you're weighing. It searches what your company actually did in comparable situations, flags the ones that went badly, and cites each past decision by ID so you can

五维评分

付费意愿
40
需求真实度
45
个人可落地
60
竞争空间
45
新鲜度
65

AI 分析

痛点:企业过去的决策记录散落在Slack、无人打开的老文档和复盘里,团队反复做相似决策、重复踩同一个坑,却没有可追溯的历史依据。

目标用户:中大型公司的产品/工程/运营决策者,以及需要频繁做重复性决策的团队(尤其是有复盘文化的科技公司)。

证据:The problem: every company has already made the decision you're about to make. It's in a Slack thread from 18 months ago, a doc nobody reopens, and a postmortem that says "this has happened before" with nothing behind it. / The risk level isn't a model's opinion, it's computed from the recorded outcomes of those past decisions, which is what makes it checkable. / When your history has nothing, it says no_precedent rather than stretching an analogy.

变现:B2B 席位订阅制(按决策者人数/月收费),连接 Slack + Notion/Confluence 作为增值模块;也可按“已归档决策条数”或查询量做用量计费,先做 3-5 家设计合作伙伴的年付试点。

MVP:2周MVP:只接一个数据源(Slack 导出 JSON 或 Notion 数据库),把历史决策切片向量化并打上“结果好/坏”标签;用户输入新决策 → 返回最相似的 3-5 条历史决策 + 结果标注 + 原始链接引用;无匹配时硬编码返回 no_precedent 并列出已检索范围。暂不做本地分类器,用现成 embedding + 规则排序即可。

竞品:Glean、Notion AI Q&A、Mem、Dust、Cloverpop

摘要:一位独立开发者在 r/SideProject 发布“记忆驱动的决策评审器”:输入待做决策,系统检索公司过去相似决策、标出翻车案例并附决策ID引用,风险等级由历史结果计算而非模型主观判断;无历史时强制返回 no_precedent。技术上用 Hindsight 做记忆层、容器内跑 421M 参数分类器做路由。帖子只是求反馈,没有任何付费意愿原话或收入数据,需求真实性尚未被他人验证。