📡 Idea Radar 每天 8:00 / 18:00 推送 · 18:00 生成精选
reddit · SideProject · 52 分 ← 返回列表

I built EdgeCheck: a trading journal you can’t lie to, that tells you if your edge is real or just noise (free 30-day beta)

Hi everyone, I’m the developer of EdgeCheck. Like a lot of traders, I kept fooling myself with my own journal: I’d log trades after the fact, “remember” entries better than they really were, or quietly skip the ugly ones. So my “edge” always looked better on paper than in my account. EdgeCheck is built around one idea: your records should be honest enough to tell you the truth. Here’s how it works. https://edgecheck-three.vercel.app 1. Lock the trade before you know the result Wh

五维评分

付费意愿
48
需求真实度
38
个人可落地
82
竞争空间
35
新鲜度
58

AI 分析

痛点:交易者事后补记或美化交易日志,导致无法判断自己的交易优势(edge)是真实统计优势还是随机噪音

目标用户:有复盘习惯的散户及半专业交易者(外汇、期货、股票日内或波段)

证据:I kept fooling myself with my own journal: I'd log trades after the fact, "remember" entries better than they really were, or quietly skip the ugly ones. / Once it's locked, it can't be edited. / After 30 trades it compares your real results with that baseline and gives you a clear verdict: a real edge, or results that random entries would also have given you.

变现:Freemium 订阅:免费版限 30 笔或 1 个策略,Pro 版 10-25 美元/月解锁无限交易、多策略对比、券商 CSV 导入与统计显著性报告

MVP:两周 MVP:单用户 Web 应用,交易进场时锁定字段(品种、方向、入场、止损、目标、风险金额)并写入服务器时间戳,禁止事后编辑(10 分钟内可删);结束后标记止盈、止损或提前平仓;用蒙特卡洛模拟相同止损止盈的随机入场基准,在 30 笔后输出 R 倍数统计与『edge 还是噪音』结论页

竞品:TradeZella、TraderVue、Edgewonk、TradesViz、TraderSync

摘要:独立开发者在 r/SideProject 发布 EdgeCheck,核心理念是交易日志在进场时锁定且不可编辑、带服务器时间戳,30 笔后用随机入场基准对比给出『真实 edge 还是噪音』的判决,目前是免费 30 天 beta。帖子只体现作者自身痛点,没有任何收入、付费用户或他人附和的证据,而交易日志赛道已有 TradeZella、TraderVue、Edgewonk 等成熟付费产品。差异化点在于『防自欺 + 统计显著性判定』,单人或小团队两周内可做出核心 MVP。