📡 Idea Radar 每天 8:00 / 18:00 推送 · 18:00 生成精选
reddit · SideProject · 50 分 ← 返回列表

I built a trading journal and turned it into a full trading dashboard.

The Process Three years ago I got fascinated with discretionary trading, mainly with trying to optimize the process and make it as consistent as possible. As I experimented with sim trading real markets, I realized that a big part of it was risk management and systemizing the way I traded so I could be as rational as possible. Initially, I thought writing down trades and tracking my P&L would be effective, so I downloaded a free trading journal. After a couple of months, I

五维评分

付费意愿
45
需求真实度
50
个人可落地
75
竞争空间
30
新鲜度
35

AI 分析

痛点:现有交易日志只能记录盈亏和截图,无法把交易思路、执行过程与结果关联起来,导致交易者反复犯同样的错误。

目标用户:自主裁量交易者、零售交易员、需要复盘和风险管理系统化的交易者。

证据:After a couple of months, I realized all I was doing was recording the same mistakes. The P&L told me nothing that I didn't already know. Even though I had an extensive amount of screenshots, I could never really connect the thought process to the result.

变现:订阅制 SaaS:免费基础交易日志,高级分析、自动化导入、多账户、交易论点模板和复盘工作流按月收费;也可提供一次性买断桌面版。

MVP:2 周内做一个轻量交易日志:支持手动/CSV 导入交易,强制填写交易论点,关联截图、情绪和复盘标签,用仪表盘展示错误模式与 P&L 的关联。

竞品:TraderVue、Edgewonk、TradesViz、TraderSync、TradingDiary

摘要:发帖人花三年做自主裁量交易,最初用免费交易日志几个月后发现只能记录重复错误,P&L 和截图无法连接交易思路与结果,于是自己开发并迭代一年,做成包含盘前计划、交易论点、执行记录、盘后复盘和分析数据库的完整交易仪表盘。帖子是产品发布,没有收入或明确付费意愿数据,但痛点真实且已有大量竞品。