📡 Idea Radar 每天 8:00 / 18:00 推送 · 18:00 生成精选
reddit · SideProject · 54 分 ← 返回列表

I built a crypto trading dojo that scores discipline, not profit. What's broken?

Hi, I'm Sekhar. I built Neeyum. I kept seeing the same advice for beginners: have a plan, set a stop loss, don't revenge trade. The practice apps I tried still let me click through all of that. So I built one that doesn't. Neeyum is an Android app for practising BTC and ETH options with virtual money only. There are no deposits. Trade Guard caps how many trades you can take in a day, and how much virtual loss you can take. You move through a belt journey (White, Yellow, Blue, Brown, Black

五维评分

付费意愿
45
需求真实度
38
个人可落地
85
竞争空间
52
新鲜度
66

AI 分析

痛点:新手交易者知道要设止损、不要报复性交易,但市面上的模拟盘 App 允许你随时违反自己的规则,缺少一个强制纪律、按行为而非盈亏评分的练习环境

目标用户:加密货币期权/合约交易新手、想训练交易纪律的散户、交易教育机构学员

证据:"Discipline Mode (the paid plan) gives you 2, plus a tighter daily loss guard, a stop loss required from White belt, a minimum risk-to-reward, and a journal that asks why you took the trade" / "The leaderboard is ranked by Behaviour Score, not P&L." / "What would you change before you'd actually practise on it?"

变现:Freemium 订阅制(Discipline Mode 月付/年付),叠加进阶交易纪律课程、付费社群或教练陪练;后期可把行为评分 API 卖给交易教育机构/Prop Firm 做学员筛选

MVP:2周MVP:只做 BTC 一个标的的虚拟下单,加硬性风控拦截(每日交易次数上限、浮亏上限直接锁单、必须填止损才能下单),加一个极简交易理由日志,用一个可解释的纪律分(守规则率、过度交易、报复性下单等)算出分数并做单人趋势图;排行榜、腰带体系和ETH先不做

竞品:TradingView Paper Trading、Thinkorswim paperMoney、Webull Paper Trading、TradeZella、TradeSim / 各类 stock market simulator App

摘要:印度独立开发者 Sekhar 独自用手机开发了 Android 应用 Neeyum,只做虚拟资金的 BTC/ETH 期权练习,用每日交易次数上限、强制止损、纪律分和腰带等级(白带到黑带)替代盈亏排行榜。免费版每天5笔交易,付费 Discipline Mode 每天只有2笔,但风控更严、强制写交易理由日志。帖子没有任何收入或用户数据,也还没验证别人是否愿意为“更少交易次数”付费,机会方向成立但需求尚未被验证。